Return to
the Overcoming Consumerism
Index
Quotes from The Dream Deferred Phillip Slater,
1991
"The private citizen mask is the one that corporations like best and
employ most often, especially when the public expresses concern over
some potentially nefarious activity,or one with a destructive social
or enviromental impact: corporate leaders react as if the police were
peering in their bedroom windows and talk of their privacy being
invaded. They want to "get government of 'our' backs"--as if they,
the corporations, and we, the people, were all in the same boat.
Yet let one of these giant "individuals" begin to lose money and the
Private Citizen mask is whisked away faster than you can say
"bailout" to be immediately replaced with the Public Institution
mask. Suddenly the corporation is not private at all, but a noble
service organization providing the community with employment and a
product which has long been part of the American tradition and should
be treated with all the respect due an endangered species. As a
"public Institution," it obviously deserves a handout from the
government: the failure of a badly managed bank would threaten the
stability of the entire community: and if a badly run manufacturing
company were allowed to collapse, what would happen to all the
workers? The success of this mask is apparent: small businesses may
rise and fall by the thousands, but above a certain size no major
corporation is allowed to collapse,no matter how badly it
performs.
But suppose we were to take them up on this pose and say, "Yessiree,
you surely do employ a lot of workers, and maybe you ought to give us
sixty days notice before you suddenly pull up stakes and transfer
your whole operation to Mexico or Taiwan where the labor's so much
cheaper." Whisk! The Public Institution mask is gone faster than you
can say "profit margin," and we find ourselves contemplating a brand
new face: the
struggling-small-business-that's-gotta-do-what-it's-gotta-do-to-make-a-buck.
If they have to bother about the welfare of their labor force, they
protest, it's good-bye to profits. They are a private business, and
they shouldn't have to be forced to contend with all these rules and
regulations.
Whenever they have to deal with federal regulatory agencies,
corporations like to dress up in short pants and beanies and
masquerade as the little-guy-fighting-against-big-government. This is
a hard one to carry off, given the that the corporation has a
squadron of expensive lawyers and accountants to stare down a handful
of underpaid functionaries who represent--however inadequately--the
will of the public.
When all else fails, corporations will pull out the
Avuncular-Institution-For-Widows-And-Orphans mask. They will plead
for all the "little people" who have entrusted their hard-earned
pennies to the corporation and deserve a return on investment. (Such
people, of course, are a tiny minority of the stockholders, and have
little or no impact on its policies.)
Large corporations shuffle these disguises with consummate skill, and
given their extraordinary wealth and power (and the highly paid
lawyers, accountants, lobbyists, public relations experts, and
advertising firms they retain), it isn't surprising that they are so
often able to frustrate and negate the will of the people by their
ability to manipulate legislatures, public officials, the media, and
the courts."
end
Slater
Back to Research Corporate Boards
Influence and Potential Corruption page
Overcoming
Consumerism Index